Skip to content

Sign Up For Our Newsletter For A Discount Code!

A player holding metal dice over a rainbow dice tray, with painted miniatures and terrain on a tabletop RPG map

The Best Tabletop RPGs Beyond D&D, Sorted by What Your Table Wants

The best tabletop RPGs beyond D&D depend on what your table wants next. For D&D with more crunch, play Pathfinder Second Edition, Tales of the Valiant or Starfinder. For a new fantasy system, try Daggerheart. For horror, Call of Cthulhu or Vampire: The Masquerade. For sci-fi, Cyberpunk Red or Shadowrun. For story first, Blades in the Dark or Fate Core. Most of these tabletop RPGs run on the seven-dice set you already own. The rest need a fistful of d6s or d10s, two d12s or four Fate dice, and we list which is which below.

Compare the dice, trays and bags in our Pathfinder collection if Pathfinder is your first stop; we make them in partnership with Paizo, the game's publisher.

We also checked what tables actually play. StartPlaying's 2024 top 49, published in February 2025 by the site that matches players with game masters, puts D&D 5e first, then Pathfinder 2e, Vampire: The Masquerade 5th Edition, Pathfinder 1e, Call of Cthulhu and Cyberpunk Red. Eight of our ten picks sit in that top 31. Daggerheart came out after the list, and Fate placed 46th.

If your table wants D&D with more crunch

These three keep the d20 at the center, so your gaming group's dice and most of its Dungeons and Dragons instincts carry straight over to the new game system.

Pathfinder Second Edition

Paizo built Pathfinder on the d20 system, then rebuilt it as Pathfinder Second Edition in August 2019. Among the key changes is a streamlined action economy. The Remaster rulebooks, Player Core, GM Core, Monster Core and Player Core 2, replaced the original Core Rulebook and its companions across 2023 and 2024 and remain compatible with older Second Edition supplements.

It is the crunchier choice. Expect more character building options, more tactical turns and more rules to look up in the first few sessions. Second place on StartPlaying's list says plenty of tables think that is worth it.

Dice: the standard seven-dice set. Our Pathfinder line, made with Paizo, includes a goblin inclusion 16mm set, a plush goblin dice bag, a map dice tray and a rolling scroll. The story of that line is in our Paizo partnership post.

Pathfinder Accessory Kit box with a velvet dice tray, dice bag and dice set, from FanRoll's Paizo Pathfinder collection

Tales of the Valiant

Kobold Press released Tales of the Valiant in 2024: the Player's Guide came out as a PDF in May and in print that July. It runs on Black Flag Roleplaying and is built to be 5E-compatible. Kobold Press says that with the Player's Guide and the Monster Vault you can run any published 5E adventure without conversion.

If your group likes 5e but wants a publisher's fresh take on the classes and rules, this is the shortest step sideways from Dungeons and Dragons.

Dice: the same seven-dice set you use for D&D.

Starfinder Second Edition

Starfinder is Paizo's science fiction game, with starships, space combat and faster-than-light travel. The first edition grew out of Pathfinder's first edition and the d20 system. The second edition launched in the summer of 2025 and follows many of the conventions of Pathfinder Second Edition, so a Pathfinder table can switch genres without relearning everything.

Dice: the standard seven-dice set. We teamed up with Paizo on a commemorative liquid core d20 for the second edition launch; it is sold out as of November 2026.

If your table wants a new fantasy system

Daggerheart

Darrington Press released Daggerheart on May 20, 2025, with Matthew Mercer among its designers. The hook is the Duality Dice: two d12s in different colors, one for Hope and one for Fear. Every action roll uses both. Which die rolls higher shapes how the scene turns, earning a Hope token for the player or a Fear token for the game master.

That one mechanic gives the game master a resource to spend, and GamesRadar+ praised it for making the game master's job easier. It is the newest major fantasy game on this list, and it showed up in the related searches for D&D alternatives when we checked in November 2026.

Dice: two d12s in two different colors for every action roll. Pull a pair from two sets you already own and you are ready for session zero. For an LGBTQIA+ friendly group, start with the queer-led events Tabletop Gaymers runs at conventions.

If your table wants horror and mystery

Call of Cthulhu

Chaosium published Call of Cthulhu in 1981, designed by Sandy Petersen, and it has stayed a classic game of horror ever since. Your investigators dig into cosmic horror and mysteries drawn from the fiction of H. P. Lovecraft. The rules use Chaosium's Basic Role-Playing system: you roll percentile dice and try to come in equal to or under your skill score.

It sits fifth on StartPlaying's list, and it is the game to pick if your players like research, clues and a slow build of dread more than combat.

Dice: two d10s read as a percentile. Every standard seven-dice set already includes the plain d10 and the percentile d10 (00 to 90), so one set per player covers it.

Vampire: The Masquerade Fifth Edition

Vampire is politics, hunger and personal horror. Fifth Edition rolls pools of ten-sided dice, and each point of your character's Hunger swaps one regular die in the pool for a red Hunger die. Those red dice decide how messy a success gets or how bad a failure turns.

It was third on StartPlaying's 2024 list, ahead of every other game here except Pathfinder. The official dice set ships with 13 black d10s and 5 red Hunger d10s, which tells you how big a pool gets.

Dice: a pile of d10s in two colors. Pick one color for regular dice and another for Hunger.

If your table wants sci-fi and cyberpunk

Cyberpunk Red

R. Talsorian Games released Cyberpunk Red in 2020, the latest edition of Mike Pondsmith's game set in Night City. Checks are simple: your stat plus your skill plus a d10 against a Difficulty Value. Character creation gives you a choice: assign points to skills, or roll d10s for a more random character.

Sixth on StartPlaying's list, and the pick for a table that wants street-level sci-fi with fast rolls.

Dice: d10s for every check, so keep a few within reach.

Shadowrun, Sixth World

Catalyst Game Labs published Shadowrun, Sixth World on August 26, 2019. It is set in a near-future world changed by a massive magical event, where runners steal data and break into rival corporations for pay. You add your attribute and skill, roll that many d6s, and count every 5 and 6 as a hit against a threshold.

Pool games like this are where a dice hoard pays off. A big pool means a big handful, and Shadowrun is the game for players who like rolling one.

Dice: a lot of d6s. Our Shadowrun Ammo dice set is a 6-piece d6 set shaped like bullet casings, and a pound of metal d6s holds approximately 18 to 20 solid zinc dice for a whole table.

FanRoll Shadowrun Ammo dice set: six brass and silver d6 dice shaped like bullet casings, in front of the Shadowrun box

If your table wants story first

Blades in the Dark

John Harper's Blades in the Dark, published by Evil Hat Productions in 2017, is a crime game. The players are a crew of criminals pulling scores, from heists to smuggling, in Doskvol, an industrial city where the sun has died and the dead come back as ghosts. Players resolve actions by rolling a pool of six-sided dice. Its Forged in the Dark rules became an engine other designers build on.

It ranked 14th on StartPlaying's list. Pick it if your group plans heists better than it fights dungeons.

Dice: a handful of d6s per player; a small pile in the middle of the table does the job.

Fate Core

Fate Core, from Evil Hat, is a toolkit for building your own game in any genre, from high fantasy to noir. You roll four Fate dice. Each one has two plus sides, two minus sides and two blank sides, and you add them up for a result from minus 4 to plus 4. Characters run on aspects, short phrases that describe who they are and can be invoked at the table.

Dice: four Fate dice, ideally a set per player. Fate dice are six-sided dice marked with plus, minus and blank faces. No Fate dice yet? The Fate rules offer a stand-in: roll four ordinary d6s and read 1 and 2 as minus, 3 and 4 as blank, 5 and 6 as plus.

FanRoll infographic: pick a tabletop RPG by what your table wants, from Pathfinder and Tales of the Valiant for more crunch to Blades in the Dark and Fate Core for story first

Which dice each game uses

Game Publisher Core dice What to have on the table
Pathfinder Second Edition Paizo d20 plus the full set One seven-dice set per player
Tales of the Valiant Kobold Press d20 plus the full set One seven-dice set per player
Starfinder Second Edition Paizo d20 plus the full set One seven-dice set per player
Daggerheart Darrington Press Two d12 Duality Dice Two d12s in different colors per player
Call of Cthulhu Chaosium Percentile (two d10s) The d10 and percentile d10 from any set
Vampire: The Masquerade Fifth Edition World of Darkness (Paradox Interactive) Pools of d10s with Hunger dice A pile of d10s in two colors
Cyberpunk Red R. Talsorian Games d10 A few d10s per player
Shadowrun, Sixth World Catalyst Game Labs Pools of d6s, 5 and 6 are hits A large pile of d6s
Blades in the Dark Evil Hat Productions Pools of d6s A handful of d6s per player
Fate Core Evil Hat Productions Four Fate dice A set of four Fate dice per player
FanRoll infographic: the dice each tabletop RPG uses, from a seven-dice set for d20 games to d6 and d10 pools, two d12 Duality Dice and four Fate dice

If you are buying for a d20 game, start with how to pick the best DnD dice, which covers size, material and readability, and our DnD dice range. Our guide to the seven dice explains the percentile d10 for anyone switching to Call of Cthulhu.

Four more worth a look

These sit further down StartPlaying's 2024 list, and each one plays differently from the ten above.

  • Star Wars RPG (Fantasy Flight Games, 2012). Tenth on the list. Set in the Star Wars universe, it rolls a pool of custom narrative dice marked with symbols instead of numbers, so the dice tell part of the story. The West End Games version from 1987 used the D6 System instead, and Fantasy Flight reprinted it for a 30th anniversary edition in 2018.
  • Savage Worlds (Pinnacle Entertainment Group). Sixteenth. Every trait is rated by die size, from a d4 at the low end to a d12 at the top, so a stronger character rolls a bigger die. It is a generic game system built to handle just about anything.
  • Star Trek Adventures (Modiphius Entertainment, 2017). Forty-fourth. It runs on a modified version of Modiphius's 2d20 System, so bring several d20s.
  • Delta Green (Arc Dream Publishing, standalone game 2016). Thirty-fifth. Modern conspiracy horror that keeps the percentile dice of Basic Role-Playing and Call of Cthulhu, with lethal weapon rules on top.

A board game for RPG fans: HeroQuest

HeroQuest is a dungeon-crawl board game, not a roleplaying game, but it lands on a lot of the same tables. One player acts as the game master, called Zargon in North America, while the others play the heroes. We make an officially licensed HeroQuest First Light dice tray; the matching dice set is sold out as of November 2026.

FanRoll HeroQuest First Light dice tray: a purple velvet tray printed with HeroQuest art, beside its box

Switching RPG systems is also a good moment to rethink how you run the game at your gaming table. Our dungeon master tips work for anyone running games in any system, and if you want to bring a new system to students, the case for a school D&D club and how to start a club cover the setup. For other RPG systems we could not fit here, Wikipedia keeps a list of tabletop role-playing games.

Tabletop RPG questions

What is the best tabletop RPG for beginners?

The best tabletop RPG for beginners is usually the one somebody in your gaming group or at your local game store already runs, because a game master who knows the rules teaches faster than any book. On StartPlaying's 2024 list, D&D 5e and Pathfinder 2e lead. If your group knows D&D, Tales of the Valiant runs on the same 5E rules.

What are the most popular TTRPGs?

D&D 5e is the most popular, followed on StartPlaying's 2024 top 49 by Pathfinder 2e, Vampire: The Masquerade 5th Edition, Pathfinder 1e, Call of Cthulhu and Cyberpunk Red. That list, published in February 2025, ranks the games players chose on that site, so treat it as one data point, not a census.

Are there games like D&D but simpler?

Yes, if simpler means fewer kinds of dice and fewer numbers to add. Fate Core uses four Fate dice and a ladder from minus 4 to plus 4, and Blades in the Dark uses a pool of d6s. Both lean on story over tactical combat.

Previous Post Next Post
Your source for premium quality dice
FanRoll