Misfit dice are FanRoll's mystery dice: blind packs of real, playable dice that we never matched into a set, or that have small cosmetic flaws. You don't pick the color. You open the bag or box, let fate decide, and find out what you got. No two packs are guaranteed to be alike. If you like the surprise of a pull, or you want more dice for less money, misfits are the easiest way to grow a collection.
This guide is for players and dice goblins who keep seeing "mystery misfit" on our store and want to know what is actually in each pack. We cover what a misfit is, which packs you can buy right now, what each one costs, and how to get the most out of a random set at the table.
What are misfit dice?
Misfits are our factory seconds. Our Misfits collection says it plainly: misfits are discounted because of minor scratches, dents or other aesthetic imperfections from the factory. It would be a shame for good dice to go to waste, so we sell them at a lower price instead.
That does not mean every misfit is flawed. Plenty of dice in these packs have nothing wrong with them at all. Some are simply extra dice that never got matched into a complete set. Either way, they are fully functional dice you use the same way as any standard polyhedral dice set, and they cost less than a first quality set that matches.
A misfit dice set is still a working polyhedral dice set. A standard poly set has 7 dice: d4, d6, d8, d10, d10 (00 to 90), d12 and d20. That covers every roll in a D&D campaign or any other tabletop roleplaying game, so a mystery bag can be your main dice, a backup set for your next adventure, or a loaner for the new player who forgot theirs. If you would rather pick your colors, our DnD dice are matched sets.
Mystery misfit dice assortments you can buy right now
Our Misfits collection covers resin dice, metal dice and gemstone dice, and which packs are in stock changes often, so search the collection before you shop. These are the mystery misfit packs we have in stock as of this update. Prices below are the current prices in our shop.
Mystery Misfit Sharp Edge Resin: $39.99
Our Mystery Misfit Sharp Edge Resin blind pack puts a randomly assorted poly set of premium, handcrafted sharp edge resin dice in every box. It is the best value way to try a sharp edge dice set without hunting for one exact color. Sharp edge resin dice are cast and then hand polished instead of tumbled, so the dice keep crisp edges and corners. Every box is a chance at a different style. If you want to know why players love that look, read our guide to sharp edge dice.

Mystic Mines Misfit Gemstone Dice Set: $49.99
The Mystic Mines Misfit Gemstone Dice Set is our most premium mystery box. Each one holds a complete gemstone dice set of 7 dice that we did not have time to match, so you get a random mix of stones. The product page lists possibilities from our best selling opalite to our premium amethyst, plus rose quartz, blue sandstone, picture jasper, cat's eye, turquoise, carnelian, tiger's eye, hematite, labradorite, obsidian, coral fossil, rainbow fluorite, lapis lazuli, imperial stone, amazonite, jade and more, all the way up to ultra rare frosted glass.
Like every misfit, some of these dice may have minor issues such as off center or scratched numbers, while others are simply assorted gemstone dice of varying rarity. Stone has real weight in the hand and can chip, so roll it on a padded surface. Our gemstone dice guide covers weight, hardness and care.

Misfit Liquid Core D20 2 Pack: $24.99
Want the showpiece without the full set? The Misfit Liquid Core D20 2 Pack is a blind bag with 2 premium liquid core d20s in a random mix of colors. Two d20s means one for normal rolls and one for advantage, or one for you and one for the DM.
Are mystery dice worth it?
Mystery dice are worth it if you care more about the fun of the pull and the price than about picking an exact color. Here is the honest trade.
| Mystery misfit pack | Named set | |
|---|---|---|
| Color and style | Random, you find out when you open it | You choose exactly what you get |
| Condition | May have small cosmetic flaws, many have none | First quality |
| Price | Lower | Higher |
| Best for | Dice goblins, backups, gifts, trying a new material | Matching a character or completing a collection |
If you need a dice set that matches your character's look to the shade, buy the named set at full price. If you want more dice in the bag, a surprise to open, or a cheaper way to try sharp edge or gemstone before you commit, a mystery misfit pack is the better purchase. Buying for the whole party? Set the quantity on the product page and everyone gets their own pull.
How to get the most out of a misfit set
- Use it as a backup. A random dice set lives in the bag for the night your favorite set goes missing under the couch.
- Keep a loaner set. New players at your table will need dice. A misfit set is an easy one to hand over.
- Mix and match. Pull the best d20 from two packs and build your own set. Nobody says a set has to match.
- Roll on a tray. Gemstone and sharp edge resin both do better on a soft landing. Our padded dice trays protect the dice and the table.
For cleaning and storage by material, our dice care and maintenance guide has the details, and our dice collection guide covers how to build a collection around what you pull. You can see every pack we carry in our Misfits collection.
Misfit dice FAQ
What does misfit mean on FanRoll dice?
A misfit is a die we sell at a discount because it has a minor scratch, dent or other cosmetic imperfection from the factory, or because it is leftover stock that was never matched into a set. Not every misfit has a flaw.
Do misfit dice roll differently?
Our misfits are sold for small cosmetic issues, such as off center or scratched numbers. They are real dice you can use in any game that calls for a polyhedral dice set.
How many dice are in a mystery misfit set?
The Mystic Mines gemstone set is a complete set of 7 dice. The Mystery Misfit Sharp Edge Resin pack holds a full poly set of sharp edge resin dice. The Misfit Liquid Core D20 2 Pack holds 2 d20s.
Can I choose the color of a misfit pack?
No. Every pack is random, and that is the point of a mystery pack. If you want a specific color or style, shop our named dice sets instead, where the photo shows exactly the set you get.
Are mystery dice a good gift?
Yes, for any player who enjoys a surprise. A mystery pack is easy to wrap, and the person opening it gets the fun of the pull too. If you are not sure what dice they already own, a random set is a safe pick, since even we don't know what is inside.


